Garment District Neighbourhood Association
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
  • DEVELOPMENT
    • Ace Hotel
    • King Portland
    • Manga Hotel
    • Waterworks
    • Woodsworth
    • 445 Adelaide
    • 544 King
    • 149 Bathurst
    • 8-18 Camden
    • 39-47 Camden
    • 580 King
    • 590 King
    • 123 Portland
    • 135 Portland
    • 450 Richmond
    • 457 Richmond
    • 520 Richmond
    • 543 Richmond
    • 96 Spadina
    • Nearby >
      • King Toronto
      • The Well
      • 64-86 Bathurst
      • 164 Bathurst
      • 415 King
      • 663 King
      • 241 Richmond
      • 464 Queen
      • 101 Spadina
      • 147 Spadina
      • 424 Wellington
  • INITIATIVES
    • ONTARIO LINE
    • ST ANDREWS PLAYGROUND
    • YMCA
    • CITY PLANNING
  • RESOURCES
    • LINKS
    • HOW TO
451 - 457 Richmond Street West

Now we wait for the decision

6/17/2019

2 Comments

 
​Well it’s done.
Today the LPAT (aka OMB) hearing related to this development application ended … in four SHORT days instead of ten LONG days.  The Chair was Mr. Reid Rossi; the appellant Mr. Dani Cohen was represented by Ms. Eileen Costello and the City by Mr. Ray Kallio.  The GDNA was represented by myself, Valerie Eggertson (GDNA Secretary) backed by a very strong team:  Ann Marie Strapp (Chair of our Development Committee) and Participants Eris Ritcey (32 Camden), Doug van Fraassen (Fabrik), Kelly Nixon (Morgan) and Max Allen (Grange Community Association). 
The hearing itself was a whirlwind … the Chair cut off witnesses and counsel alike when they didn’t stay focused.  No reciting of official plans or bylaws here, no reiterating issues, no augmenting explanations once the Chair had grasped the point!  The Chair also asked that the witnesses be called not in the usual “appellant first, City next” order but by subject … hence heritage issues were addressed by both sides on day two and urban design issues on day three.
These scheduling changes did cause some degree of angst to the legal counsels but definitely added to my enjoyment of the proceedings.  I found it much easier to hear arguments and counter-arguments within the same day rather than a week apart.
All the witnesses, for both City and appellant, were strong and effective.  The Participants were particularly blessed that the City’s Urban Design witness, Joseph Luk, created some amazing visuals which only reinforced their particular issues (separation distances of the proposal from the Fabrik outdoor amenity space and the north facing balconies of 32 Camden; the sky views from the north facing balconies and the outdoor amenity space of 32 Camden).  A special call-out to Richard Eriksson who, a few weeks earlier, had invited Joseph into his suite and the public spaces at 32 Camden to take photographs.
If you are interested in reviewing these particular visuals, click here ... it is a 21.5 MB file.  Page 37 presents the City’s preferred built form which the GDNA endorsed in closing arguments, remaining neutral however on the issue of heritage retention.  Pages 40, 43, 45, 47 and 48 illustrate the effect of the submitted proposal on nearby condos.
Chairman Rossi has promised a speedy resolution to this file … weeks rather than months.  So now we wait.
Picture
These hearings are definitely not kind to forests. Here are the GDNA takeaways.
2 Comments
Dieter Riedel
6/18/2019 01:47:58 pm

Wow, I think our GDNA development team deserves a drink! Is there a budget line item for "OMB- LPAT alcoholic recovery libations"?

I believe I have encountered Mr. Rossi as chair once before - either for the prior version of 544 King Street back in 2009, or for the Thompson Residences on King Street - can't remember which. If it is the latter, I can only hope that the weight of the LPAT transformation weighs on him a little more than in the past.

That aside, the whole event sounds like a horror show. Why have a "court" session like this if everything ends up being rushed or brushed off?

Reply
Patricia Aquino
6/18/2019 02:50:02 pm

Congratulations Development Committee for making it through in such a short period of time and being productive, thorough and effective.

No matter what Chairperson Rossi's resolution is, I'm grateful to the Team for your on-going commitment to the GDNA mission to build and promote an attractive, inclusive, safe and sustainable community ♥️

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    April 2020
    January 2020
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    August 2017
    March 2017
    December 2016

    Picture
    Re-zoning application #
    16 268947 STE 20 OZ


    OMB case #
    ​PL170832

Location

Contact Us